The right answer depends on where you are in the process. At a recruiter screen, deflect first: ask for the posted range. Most employers have one and asking for it is not awkward. If pressed, give a wide research-based range and avoid anchoring until you know the full scope of the role. At the offer stage, once the employer has decided they want you, anchor first. The first number in a negotiation pulls the outcome toward it. Research the 50th-to-75th percentile band for the role, title, and geography using government wage databases, industry surveys, and professional salary reports. State the top of that band as your opening, framing it as market-aligned, not personal. Cite the research, not your needs.
Insider read
Really testing: Whether you know the recruiter screen is too early to anchor and that your research range, not your current salary, should set the opening number.
The tell: Candidates who give a precise number at the recruiter stage have anchored low and exposed their floor. Strong negotiators deflect early, research the band, and anchor at the top of market when they have enough information.
Follow-up: The recruiter shares a range that is below what your research found. What do you do?
Say this"I would tell them my research across several sources puts the market band for this scope higher, name that band, and ask how much flexibility exists. If the range truly cannot move, I decide whether to continue based on the top of their range, not the middle."